Movie Review: The Blind Side (2009) & its "Christian" message

As of today, The Blind Side is 2009's 9th highest grossing film based almost exclusively word-of-mouth promotion. The critical reception has been mediocre at best, but audiences continue to laud it and promote it. The secret...well, it's not much of a secret. It's being promoted as a Christian film.

I won't really go into what I thought of the film, nor will I discuss Christianity in the movie biz (a far too weighty topic for a mere college student). But I'm fascinated by the implications that this film has a "Christian" message and I want to examine exactly how the film can be seen as such. I'll try to remain as objective as possible, but expect some snark. Oh, and spoilers ahoy off the starboard bound. Read on, brave ones, if you've seen Blind Side already. Or read it anyway and spoil it. Your choice.

A word about the audience as I see it. The Christian influence on the success of films is notoriously under-appreciated by critics and Hollywood elite. Just look at The Golden Compass (2007) for the smoking gun. A lot of the hype about The Blind Side comes not only from the fact that it's a true story, a powerful factor indeed, but also for the fact that it's an inspirational film. And when I say inspirational, I say "remember your audience."

Well, we're done with the salad, so let's move on to the meat and potatoes. Are the characters in the film Christian?

Nominally speaking, absolutely. The Christian School is a Christian school, touting an adapted version of Matthew 19:26 above a its main entrance. No coincidence that Michael's entry through this gate is one of the better directed and most reprised shots in the film. White walls, white stones, white people... Michael's rather emo poetry does reveal his unfamiliarity with this world of upper class, conservative white Christians. So far, so characterized. But as Michael enters this supposedly Christian world, here's where things get complicated.

We are first introduced to the element of Christian morality when the football coach character (Ray McKinnon) makes his case to get Michael into school at St. Prestigious School. The coach seems like an affable dude and though we know he cares about having Michael play football, he states that bringing Michael in is the "right" thing to do. The "Christian" thing to do. And we definitely believe him. Underneath the dang seal is the word "Christian." It IS the right thing to do. Without quoting specific Bible verses, I think we can safely say that Jesus would approve.

But Michael is still neglected and has no place to stay. In a move straight from the heart, Sandra Bullock's character takes him in for more than just one night. No selfish motivation on her part. Not really even "white guilt" as her friends suggest. She does it out of the goodness of her heart. Let's face it, the Mom is a battle axe who totes poor Tim McGraw around by the throat in this movie. But when it comes to what's underneath the skin, the woman bleeds gold.

Bullock's character is by far the most Christian of the bunch. Her selfless action propels the film and takes a young kid out of a terrible situation. But it's not so black and white than that. Remember her surrounding friends? The ones with which she has that $18 salad. Charitable, upper class white women. Christians. But like a fly swatter, it's pretty clear these folks aren't the kind Christians that Ms. Tuohy is. Besides the not-so-subtle implications of racism and a general attitude of condensation, they're pretty rude to Mike and disrespectful to the Tuohy's intentions. The Blind Side tends to lump these kind of people together with the semi-pejorative term "rednecks." For the sake of simplicity, I'll keep using the term. Added to the fact that I love Jeff Foxworthy, there's something oddly self-indulgent about white, southern upper-class Christians calling each other rednecks. Or maybe it doesn't seem that way to you yet.

Let's continue. The first football game Michael plays tells a lot about the kind of Christians we're encountering in this film. The one racist redneck is at first repelled by "sticks and stones" and turning the other cheek by the Touhy fam. But as time progresses, Sandra Bullock plants a verbal foot up the man's ass. Firmly. Not to say that Christianity doesn't have something to say about sticking up for others, but it's pretty revealing when the so-called "Christian" attendees of a friendly southern football game turn ugly so fast. That's the way it IS in real life too, just in case you people reading aren't from the south. The man in the film might have well as used the "n" word. He was spouting just about everything else a PG-13 movie could take. But in addition to the repulse by Bullock, we get a lot of derision and name-calling, dumbing our opponents down into hicks and rednecks. Interesting.

To me, it's interesting that the film spends so much time separating THESE Christians (racist, mouth-breathing hicks) from Ms. Tuohy & co. The movie does make denominations of it's own by exposing the latent hypocrisies in the Christians practicing the Christianity.

Better example. A later conversation between Ms. Tuohy and Coach Cotton reveals that he pulled all of his strings to get Michael into school so he could play football. Ms. Tuohy retorts, "I thought you said it was your Christian duty." He opts not to give a Bill Clinton type response defining terms or equivocating. His silence gives us the answer. Ouch. We honestly DID believe him earlier when he gave us that meaningful speech about being a Christian school. And now he's just a hypocrite like all the other Christians in the film. No band-aid could fix this. Although it wasn't presented as a major part of the film, I definitely did a double take on this scene.

But that's the interesting part about The Blind Side isn't it? It attempts to divine what is truly Christian in its own way by effectively picking and choosing what constitutes real Christians. The most underrated scene in the movie, I think, is when they hire the tutor (the inimitable Kathy Bates). Plump, deep-hearted Kathy Bates quips that she would have taught at St. Hypocrites Christian academy but she wasn't "Christian enough" for them. Her not so subtle admission that she "has some doubts" might as well be a sign saying "Hello, my name is Atheist."And it only gets better. She pauses, saying "I might as well tell you..." cause, oh goodness, she's got some deep dark secret that might prevent her from being Michael's tutor. The words on EVERYONE'S minds in the theater were definitely "I'm a homosexual," but we're treated with the humorous admission that "I'm a democrat." In this context though, they might as well be the same thing, and that I think, is a victory for The Blind Side's emphasis on Christian tolerance. An interesting angle, don't you think?

And let's not forget Michael's attack on Ms. Tuohy upon NCAA investigation. Though we KNOW that Ms. Tuohy was being genuine in letting Michael in, she herself has doubts about her own ability to give him free choice in where he plays football. Let's pull a "stop...Hammertime" on this point. It's a fascinating psychological implication that, even in Ms. Tuohy's noble intentions, she may have accidentally manipulated poor Michael into choosing Ole Miss unfairly. What she's really asking herself is, did I do the Christian thing; did I in my own selfishness ever have the idea in my head that he'd be an asset to the school sports program? The audience clearly knows that this is a resounding "no", but the very introduction of any form of doubt about it... Well, it's certainly a strong point in the film's depth. Was it possible that her good intentions were clouded? If we consider The Blind Side as a theological film, this makes an interesting point. It MAY have been selfish... BUT what matters ultimately is that the choice is up to Michael. To those who see a "the ends seem to justify the means" conflict here, I'll say this. For the film to work, and the actual real life story to work, we have to know something about the characters. And the film does a marvelous job of giving us characters. We as the audience know that if Ms. Tuohy was REALLY concerned about sports, she'd have never told her husband to turn the car around in the first place. She did a generous thing -- the Christian thing -- out of the goodness of her heart.

All the other characters in the film can't see that. Even dopey, football-watching Tim McGraw husband can't understand that. She is the true Christian of the film. The polarization between her and all the rest is the difference between what The Blindside presents as Christianity and faux-Christianity. And without being preachy or overextended, The Blindside offers its on very specific take on what actions accompany both groups. Tolerance and diversity is as much of a "Christian" message in this film as is generosity and love towards strangers. Whether you see this is a Christian (no air quotes) message, I'll leave up to you to decide.

I'll roll this into a fine point. The Blind Side isn't a Christian movie; it's a movie with Christian character(s?) doing "Christian" things. As I think I've demonstrated from flogging a dead horse, there IS a difference.

Given what I perceive to be the Christian message of the film, it's interesting to see how the marketing of The Blind Side has advanced from being an "inspirational" film to being a "Christian" film. We'll see how the film stands the test of time with the Christian audience AND how the film does with the...well, decidedly less Christian Academy.

Funny closing: I was just watching Ben Hur... Charlton Heston makes a pretty convincing Jew. Don't believe me? Ask Charlton Heston.